Data Recovery Case File · Trust, Practice & Honest Limits · Does a Previous Attempt Raise the Price?
Data Recovery Cost: Does a Previous Attempt Raise the Price?
Her question was short, unusually well-aimed, and one this trade should answer publicly far more often. She had spoken to someone by phone about a mechanical failure of her external hard drive and been given an indicative figure. Then the complicating fact: "as I have had another company look at the device, will this cost go up?" That is a genuinely good question, and it deserves better than reassurance. The honest answer has three parts: sometimes yes, usually no, and it depends entirely on what the other company actually did — not on the fact that they looked. This page sets out what does and does not move a recovery price, why a phone figure is an estimate rather than a quote, and how the structure is meant to protect her from exactly this uncertainty.
| Media | External hard drive with a diagnosed mechanical failure — previously examined by another company; indicative figure given by telephone |
| Reported situation | Mechanical fault identified · prior third-party examination of unknown depth · owner asking whether prior involvement increases the cost before committing |
| Fault class | Mechanical failure requiring drive opening — pricing question resolved by free assessment establishing the device's actual current state |
| Equipment used | Free assessment establishing present condition and any prior intervention · Atola Insight Forensic head and media diagnostics · laminar flow bench head service with matched donor parts · PC-3000 Express with Data Extractor head-mapped imaging · fixed written figure issued before any work began |
The decode: what moves a price, what doesn't, and why the assessment is free
What genuinely changes the cost: mechanical recovery is priced on the work and the parts the fault requires — a matched donor drive sourced and consumed, skilled hours under filtered air, then a long supervised imaging run on a fragile mechanism. So the things that move a figure are the things that change that: how many heads have failed, whether the platter surfaces have been scored, how much of the disk reads only under duress, and whether a suitable donor is common or scarce. A previous examination can affect exactly one of those — if it damaged the drive further.
Why "they looked at it" usually changes nothing: most prior involvement is harmless to the price. A diagnostic session, a proper filtered-air inspection, a firm that opened the drive, looked, declined the job and closed it up correctly — none of that alters the work still required, and none of it should attract a surcharge. This archive has documented many second-opinion cases where the prior firm's work was sound and the only thing they contributed was a head start. Being examined is not a penalty.
When it does move — and why that's a fact rather than a policy: the honest exceptions are real. A drive opened outside filtered-air conditions may have taken on contamination that now has to be cleaned before anything else. Heads moved by hand, an attempted swap with a mismatched donor, or a mechanism run after being opened can convert a straightforward head replacement into surface damage that reads slowly, or into a harder job needing more parts. In those cases the cost reflects the drive's current condition — as it always would, whoever caused it. What should never happen is a firm inventing a premium simply because a competitor's name came up.
Why the phone figure isn't the quote — and what protects her: an indicative number given on a call is an experienced guess from a description, and it is offered honestly as that. The binding number comes after the free assessment, when the drive's real state is known: heads counted, surfaces examined, any prior intervention identified. Then one fixed figure is put in writing before a single screw is turned, and that figure does not move afterwards — no meter, no discoveries added later. If the assessment finds that a previous attempt has genuinely made the job harder, she is told so in writing, with the reason, and she decides. That is the whole point of assessing before pricing: she never has to gamble on the answer to her own question.
On the bench
The assessment came first and cost nothing: the drive examined for its present condition and for any traces of prior intervention, the Atola Insight Forensic establishing the head and media picture by measurement, and the findings — including exactly what the earlier examination had and had not changed — written down before any figure was issued. Her fixed written figure followed, and the work proceeded as scoped: matched donor heads fitted under the laminar flow bench, the rebuilt mechanism imaged head-mapped on the PC-3000 Express under Data Extractor, the volume verified from the image and delivered. The number she paid was the number she had read before agreeing to anything.
The outcome
Her question answered before she committed, the drive's real condition established free of charge, and the recovery completed at the fixed written figure she had already seen. Free assessment, one fixed written figure including VAT, and on drives that must be opened, 50% of parts and labour payable upfront with the balance due only on successful recovery. The answer, posted for everyone in her position: prior examination is not a surcharge, and no honest firm charges for a competitor's involvement; what can move a price is genuine additional damage — contamination, mishandled heads, a mismatched donor — and that is priced as the drive's current state, in writing, with the reason given; a telephone figure is an estimate and should be described as one; and the binding number belongs after a free assessment, not before it.
Worried a previous attempt will push your quote up
Ask the question directly, exactly as this owner did — and expect a specific answer rather than reassurance. Prior examination on its own shouldn't cost you anything: a diagnostic session, or a firm that opened the drive properly and declined the job, leaves the remaining work unchanged. What can legitimately raise a figure is added damage — a drive opened without filtered air and now contaminated, heads moved by hand, a mismatched donor fitted, or a mechanism run after being opened. If that's happened, you should be told in writing what was found and why it changes the work. Two things to insist on before committing anywhere: a free assessment that establishes the drive's actual condition, and one fixed written figure including VAT that doesn't move afterwards. Also ask what's payable upfront versus on success — on drives that have to be opened, a parts-and-labour deposit is normal and should be stated plainly.
Ask before you commit — call Leeds Data Recovery on 0113 322 3083; free assessment of the drive's real condition, findings in writing, one fixed figure including VAT before any work starts.
Request a quote online →
Our case files are drawn from genuine enquiries received by our laboratory over the past ten years, anonymised to protect client confidentiality. Each one describes the diagnostic and recovery procedure our engineers apply to that fault, using the equipment listed.